Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Margot Mainbrace's avatar

I remain a huge fan John - you've been brave in your reporting and were brave to have this conversation. I applaud you for your work and for embracing this moment of accountability. But it did feel like a bit of a cop-out to me.

In my opinion no medical professional should have supported mass distribution of a vaccine that hadn’t gone through the standard long-term testing. Especially with a pathogen with a low IFR.

IMO the novelty of the method, with years of failed attempts at coronavirus vaccines, and with years of failures in developing safe mRNA technologies, all miraculously ‘overcome’ in a very short timeline should have made healthcare workers very suspicious.

IMO it should have been a tremendous red flag when the EUA was based on a lack of alternative treatments and those other treatments were prematurely dismissed in anti-scientific ways.

IMO the trial data itself, with more all-cause mortality in the treatment group, the poorly chosen endpoints, the sloppy testing protocols and the very suspicious and asymmetrical exclusions, should have given all healthcare professionals pause.

IMO the rush to vaccinate children was not only a red flag given the terrible risk-benefit analysis, but was incredibly suspicious given the fact that getting the vaccines approved on the US childhood vaccine schedule gives the Pharma companies much broader protection against liability.

IMO many, many, people, including Jessica and Norman, weren’t merely making lucky guesses in the dark - they were providing real evidence early on based on real data, and deserve credit for seeing the truth much earlier than others.

And I say all this not with hindsight, but as a layperson who knew these things before you reported on them.

I could go on, but I do feel an opportunity was missed in this conversation, even given the limitations of YouTube. The world is watching - and that includes a lot of medical professionals who are wrestling with the dissonance of what they have done. Modelling a more complete picture of truth and reconciliation could have done us all a world of good.

Expand full comment
Caroleyene's avatar

God bless you, from the US.

Expand full comment
50 more comments...

No posts